Time to Shut Down Big Ten/ACC Challenge
Ten years was enough for the original Beverly Hills 90210. Likewise, Seinfeld, Friends, and Everybody Loves Raymond shut it down nine or ten seasons in. A good percentage of marriages that end up in divorce occur within ten years. Even my dog, Boney, only lasted ten years (Okay, he only lasted a day).
After ten years of beatdowns the ACC has put on the Big Ten, it’s time to shut down the annual challenge. Don’t get me wrong, I geek out every year watching some of the top matchups. It’s just been so watered down in the past few years with the ACC’s dominance that I think ten years is the perfect amount of time to pull the plug. The top matchups are great and definitely made for TV. As a TV viewer, I definitely don’t mind a bit. There were awesome matchups this season, just like there are every year. The product’s just been watered down. Outside of the big games, there are a lot of clunker games that seem to always involve Northwestern, Penn State, and Michigan and whoever they’re playing (Ironically NW and Penn State BOTH won this year). They don’t even put these games on ESPN or ESPN2 and there may be no worse gym in America to watch a TV game than Welsh-Ryan Arena. Outside of the big TV matchups (This year was Purdue-Duke, Michigan State-North Carolina, Ohio State-Miami, and Indiana-Wake Forest), I don’t think there’s any reason to continue the series.
It’s a forced game on a schedule early in the season and takes away versatility on the schedule. In the grand scheme of things, no one really brings up the challenge when debating bubble teams or locks when heading into the tournament. That being said, I do think the Big Ten gets a rep for being inferior when it comes to the ACC and Big East, and depending on the year the SEC, Big 12, and Pac 10. For years, I’ve said the matchups always favored the ACC, but after ten straight years of winning, I think my argument is mute. It’s not the most balanced way to set up a conference vs conference showdown, but I’m sure the Big Ten has had the advantage on key home matchups at least once in ten years. They just haven’t got the job done.
If I weren’t a Big Ten fan, I’d be all for this challenge as it does produce some nice matchups each season. Being a Big Ten guy, I say you have to scrap it. Mainly because I’m tired of losing.
I believe that would also free up IU’s schedule to get Notre Dame back on there, which wouldn’t be bad for the state of Indiana.




Powered by